Based on the search results, here are some of the best body lotions for winter in India, along with their product details, positive and negative aspects, and key ingredients:

1. Vaseline Intensive Care Deep Restore Body Lotion: This lotion is effective for winters and comes in a temper-proof, neat packaging without any leakages. The mineral oil in this lotion helps lock moisture into the skin, softens skin, and improves skin barrier function. It is ideal for dry and rough skin.

2. Nivea Nourishing Lotion Body Milk With Deep Moisture Serum: This lotion provides lasting moisturization because of its deep moisture serum formula. It keeps your skin moisturized for up to 48 hours and helps to reduce skin roughness and repair very dry skin. It is ideal for dry skin.

3. Boroplus Doodh Kesar body lotion: This lotion is made of 100% Ayurvedic ingredients and has antiseptic properties. It is ideal for dry and rough skin.

4. Forest Essentials Ultra-Rich Body Milk Indian Rose Absolute: This lotion is enriched with the goodness of rose oil and kokum butter, which provide deep hydration and nourishment to the skin. It is ideal for dry and sensitive skin.

5. Nourish Mantra Mystic Indian Rose Body Lotion: This lotion is infused with the goodness of Gotu kola, moringa, and Indian ginseng, which provide 24-hour hydration and a natural glow to the skin. It is ideal for dry skin.

6. Himalaya Cocoa Butter Intensive Body Lotion: This lotion cools your skin and leaves it feeling rejuvenated and hydrated for long hours. It is ideal for normal to dry skin.

7. Biotique Bio Winter Cherry Rejuvenating Body Nourisher: This lotion revitalizes and nourishes weather-roughened skin and makes it soft and supple. It is infused with a blend of pure winter cherry, sunflower, safflower, musk root, and almond oil that enhances the overall health and vitality of the skin and boosts its elasticity. It is ideal for dry and sensitive skin.

Positive aspects of these lotions include deep hydration, nourishment, and moisturization of the skin, while negative aspects may include a greasy or heavy feel on the skin. The key ingredients of these lotions include natural ingredients like Ayurvedic herbs, rose oil, kokum butter, and almond oil, as well as synthetic ingredients like mineral oil and glycerin.