Nate Bargatze's performance as host of the 2025 Emmys received mixed reviews. He tried to keep the show moving with a unique gimmick where he pledged $100,000 to the Boys & Girls Club of America but would deduct $1,000 from the donation for every second an acceptance speech went over 45 seconds, and add money for speeches under the limit. While this idea was creative, it was not very well received; many felt his performance lacked energy and the show felt tedious and telethon-like at times. Despite the challenges, Bargatze ultimately donated a total of $350,000 to the charity, which was more than his initial pledge. Overall, Bargatze was seen as an affable but somewhat underwhelming host who avoided politics and kept the tone light but failed to fully engage the audience with his humor and hosting style.