To make a pie in Grow a Garden (GAG), follow these general steps and recipes based on the ingredient rarity:

1. Gather ingredients according to the type of pie you want to make.
2. Combine the ingredients in Chris P.'s kitchen pot.
3. Click the "cook" button and wait for the cooking timer to finish. The wait time varies with ingredient quality and size.
4. Once cooking is done, take the pie from the pot and give it to Chris P. to earn rewards.

Here are some specific pie recipes for different rarities:

• Rare Pie: 1 Crown Melon + 1 Jalapeno
• Legendary Pie: 1 Pumpkin + 1 Apple
• Mythical Pie: 1 Pumpkin + 1 Ember Lily
• Divine Pie: 1 Sugarglaze + 1 Beanstalk
• Prismatic Pie: 1 Pumpkin + 4 Bone Blossom; or 1 Coconut + 2 Bone Blossom
• Transcendent Pie: 1 Pumpkin (or Coconut) + 4 Bone Blossom

Bone Blossom is a key ingredient for high-tier pies. Different combinations yield different pies, and Chris P. may give you special rewards if he is craving pie at the time you serve it. In summary, pick your preferred recipe, combine those ingredients in the cooking pot, wait for it to cook, and then present the pie to Chris P. for rewards.