Rolling Stone gave Taylor Swift's twelfth studio album, "The Life of a Showgirl," a perfect five-star review. The review praised Swift for ascending to a new level of superstardom, hitting every target with precision. Assistant editor Maya Georgi highlighted Swift's witty lyrics and daring approach. The album features a mix of vibrant and bold tracks, with storytelling that remains incisive and fresh. The collaboration with producers Max Martin and Shellback was noted for bringing a fresh direction, distinct from her previous work. The review emphasizes the album as a reflection of Swift's career achievements and personal growth, with a mix of theatrical flair and emotional vulnerability.

However, Rolling Stone's review also contrasts with some other critiques that found parts of the album less compelling lyrically, particularly mentioning some awkward or juvenile metaphors. Yet overall, Rolling Stone's stance is highly positive, recognizing Swift's continued dominance and artistic evolution in pop music.