From the search results, it appears that there are several makeup tutorials available for Sally from Nightmare Before Christmas. However, the product details, positive and negative aspects, and ingredients or materials used are not clearly mentioned in the titles or descriptions of the videos.

Therefore, it is difficult to provide specific information about the products used in the tutorials. However, some of the videos do mention the products used in the tutorial, such as Party City Cream Make-up in White, Fox eye tape and Smashbox photo primer.

Additionally, there is a link to a product called Painting Balayage Lightener Packette by Wella on the Sally Beauty website. The ingredients listed for this product include potassium persulfate, kaolin, sodium silicate, paraffinum, liquidum/mineral oil/oil/huile minérale, hydroxyethylcellulose, carbomer, and sodium stearate. However, it is important to note that this product is not directly related to the Sally makeup tutorials.

Overall, while the search results provide information about the makeup tutorials for Sally from Nightmare Before Christmas, they do not provide detailed information about the products used, positive or negative aspects, or ingredients or materials.