Heather Gay is a cast member of the Real Housewives of Salt Lake City who had a mysterious black eye during the shows third season. There are several theories about how she got the black eye, but Heather herself claimed during the season three reunion that she doesnt know how it happened because she blacked out. Some theories suggest that she hit her eye on a faucet in the bathroom while drunk, while others suggest that Jen Shah, another cast member, may have punched her in the face. Heather has denied that Jen hit her, and there is no concrete evidence to support any of the theories. Heather has also claimed that Bravo has footage of the incident, but it has not been released.