Heather Gay, a cast member of the reality show "The Real Housewives of Salt Lake City," had a black eye that was the subject of much speculation among fans. The mystery was finally resolved during the shows season three reunion episode, which aired on January 25, 2023. Heather admitted that she did not remember how she got the black eye, saying "I blacked out. I dont know how it happened". She had previously given conflicting stories about what happened. Some of her castmates and friends speculated that she may have been punched by another cast member, Jen Shah. However, Heather did not confirm or deny this theory. It is unclear whether Heathers black eye was the result of a physical altercation or some other cause.