"Orange Juice" by Noah Kahan is a song about a loved one who got into a traumatic drunk driving accident that was fatal for some passengers. The song is a reflection on renewal, redemption, and going through a personal transformation. The lyrics depict a scene where the narrator invites the loved one back into their life after a period of sobriety. The narrator offers orange juice to the loved one, promising that "no one will tempt you" because "we know you got sober". The song is about providing an alternative to alcohol and trying to compassionately drive the loved one towards self-forgiveness. Through this song, Kahan describes a lifetime in just a few minutes, detailing a story of pain and forgiveness that draws listeners in from the very first verse and has them crying at the end, as if they too have experienced this exact event.