The likely winner of American Idol Season 23 (2025) is John Foster, according to multiple predictions and fan polls. Foster, a charismatic country singer with a strong fan base and consistent high marks from judges, is favored by over 50% of voters and many entertainment sites like Parade and Gold Derby

. However, Jamal Roberts, an R&B singer and entertainer, is also a strong contender with significant support and is considered by many to be the deserving winner. Some polls show nearly 45% of voters believe Roberts should win, and Las Vegas betting odds currently favor him with a 71.4% probability, indicating a very close competition between him and Foster

. Breanna Nix, known for her powerful vocals and relatable story, is expected to finish third

. In summary, the top two contenders are John Foster and Jamal Roberts, with Foster slightly ahead in public and expert predictions, but the final outcome remains competitive and uncertain until the official announcement